Consumers vs Players

When was the last time you felt ‘at one’ with a game? When you knew a game’s rules and limitations like the back of your hand, when you felt that wonderful symbiotic link between your thoughts and the way your on-screen character responded, as though your fingers played no part in telling them what to do?

The pile!
This… is the pile!

For me, it feels like it’s been years. And it’s quite worrying.

You see, I buy games when they’re cheap, months after their release and when review scores, demos and word of mouth lets me know which titles to keep my thrifty eye on. Despite my money-saving tendencies, this means that I currently have a backlog of around 20 games that are either not started or incomplete – known as ‘the pile’ – all vying for my attention, trying to catch my eye whenever I cast a glance in their cellophane-wrapped direction.

When I see a bargain I can’t refuse, I buy the game and add it to the pile, slowly working my way through and occasionally putting a newer game to the front of the jostling queue leading to my Xbox 360’s disc tray. I go through a game, finish it, put it to one side and immediately start another game. I consume games; ‘consume’ rather than, y’know, ‘play’. I’ve somehow turned my passion into a to-do list1.

This is vastly different from how I used to play games back on my beloved PlayStation and PlayStation 2. With my more limited disposable income and the constant demand of homework and uni coursework, I had to be much more particular with my gaming choices. This also meant that I spent a lot more time with individual games, learning their intricacies, their boundaries and their eccentricities. Finding my new-found and hard-earned skills being matched perfectly by the challenges thrown at me. That beautiful empowering Zen-like immersion where you truly feel a part of the digital world sat before you.

A week ago I decided to boot up an old classic, something I haven’t played for some time but felt compelled to revisit2: Burnout Paradise. A game I had previously felt to be ‘completed’, despite not having acquired all of the achievements that normally preclude my parting company with a game. So I loaded the game up, with no hidden agenda (triggering achievements or boosting experience points or anything like that). I just fancied playing it. Not consuming it.

Before I knew it, a whole day had gone. After relearning the idiosyncrasies of my favourite cars, I discovered playing online with and against completely random people, a community of like-minded gamers who, on that exact day at that exact time, also felt the need to play some Burnout. For that day I was removed from my living room and dove headfirst into Paradise City, freely exploring the environment created solely for our shared enjoyment, without regard for things like gravity, 100ft drops or personal safety. Songs etched into my memory played loudly as though the game knew what I expected of it, rather than the other way around. I felt at one with the game, truly immersed, removed from reality and placed into the game. And it felt amazing.

To feel 'at one' with a game
Ahh the joys of videogame immersion!

Rather than blaming the games, I know the fault lies with me. Is it that I’m becoming worse at games, that my own skills are holding me back from the true immersion I used to so easily enjoy? That as I grow older my ability to suspend my disbelief is gradually reducing? Or is it that the only reason I keep missing opportunities to truly connect with a game is because I skim-read over as many as I can squeeze in, hoping that ‘the pile’ will one day be vanquished?3

As with most undesired behaviours, the first step is admitting you have a problem. As to the solution, I’ve got some ideas. Perhaps I should dust off my PS2 and revisit some classics. Switch notifications off on my Xbox 360 so I become less aware of Achievements. Or just take more time to get to know my games, to stop trying to rush through them and to occasionally stand still and just take things in. To not consume the games, to not just play them, but to try to truly experience them.

Now there’s a thought.

_

1  Having said that, even to-do lists can be made more engaging these days.
2  Probably after seeing this trailer for Criterion’s next release.
3  Which, quite disturbingly, sounds a bit like my dating policy while I was at uni.

Posted

in

,

by

Comments

20 responses to “Consumers vs Players”

  1. Mark P avatar

    Did I see Far Cry 2 in ‘the pile’? If so, you can just throw that right out. Right out the window. And under a steamroller.

    And you should maybe put Splinter Cell: Conviction closer to the top. 🙂

    I have this problem but only on PC with my mahoosive backlog of Steam games that are unplayed. Awesome first blog though, Gilo. 😀

  2. Albull avatar
    Albull

    Far Cry 2 was actually one of the few games which did immerse me in the last 2 years.

    I think part of the problem is turning a hobby into a profession. You can’t help but be more critical about things like music or film when you start viewing them in that way and games are no different.

    Oh and if you ever need help with your piles, Giles… try Preperation-H *gufaw*

    Seriously though Far Cry 2 and Splinter Cell need to be played before the big release season is truly upon us.

  3. Ninja avatar
    Ninja

    Achievements are the main immersion breaker for me, I think. Well, they were but I have mostly managed to block that *ping* out, much like when people talk to me while I’m reading a book. Probably the last game to immerse me was Half Life 2.

    I will admit, I do sometimes revisit old games to score points (seeing as you mentioned Burnout) but tend to forget that intention and just tear round or I’ll canter if it’s Oblivion/other horse-featuring game.

    Cool blog; quite like that you somehow have a collection of expressions that work as, er, game-y ones!

  4. Albull avatar
    Albull

    By the way: if the Gilo of Persia is not your Facebook profile picture by the end of the day there’ll be hell to pay.

  5. Mark avatar
    Mark

    Far Cry 2 is one of the ultra super very best games of this generation. It belongs at the very top.

  6. Mark P avatar

    Wait, people liked Far Cry 2? I thought it was terrible. A complete and utter travesty of a game. One that is currently disgracing my achievement list with it’s 60g worth of abomination.

  7. Mark avatar
    Mark

    It is the most exciting and radically different FPS I’ve played in a long long time.

  8. Dean avatar
    Dean

    I sometimes feel that Gilo, but i think its partly to do with nostalgia. In our fast paced gaming environment, with our achievements and social connectivity its tempting to look back through rosy lens to our childhood, and remember our experiences with games like Resident Evil, Streets of Rage and Final Fantasy 7 (a random trio of games i’m always feeling nostalgic over). In fact when i was a kid and owned a mega drive the only time i got a new game was every two months or so when my favourite Uncle decided to buy me one, and because he didn’t really have a clue (bless him) it was a rather hit and miss process, so i used to get maybe 2 or 3 great games in a year to compete for my attention. I guess that’s what made them special and meant i played them so much.

    Of course the fact that i love RPGs means that i’m forced to feel completely at one with a game thanks to things like 70 hours gameplay, level grinding and *gulp* item synthesis.

  9. The Rook avatar
    The Rook

    Sometimes going after certain achievements can help you become one with the game. The requirements make you do things you may not have tried or spent much time doing and therefore helps you become familar with an aspect of the game.

    Having gotten older (not necessarily grown up) I have the money to buy more games than I did when I was younger and I always have something to play and not have to rely on playing the same over and over. Therefore, I too have a ‘pile’ of games requiring attention.

    Nice first blog Giles.

    I am hoping to become one with taking down zombies in Dead Rising 2.

  10. Giles avatar

    Thanks for the feedback everyone, tis a proud moment seeing blog #1 out in the wild and made all the better by the warm welcome! And a Gilo No-Prize to the first person who can name the three games in the second image – with the right subtitles! ^_^

    Right, in order:

    Mark P: I’m really keen to give Far Cry 2 a go at some point as I think Clint Hocking is awesome, and it sounds really different from all other FPS titles out there. But it seems to be one of those massive games that need a week off work to get the best out of it…as opposed to the need-a-month-off-work JRPGs sat in the pile.

    Albull: I think you’re partly right about when hobbies become professions. In the same way as when you study something you love at uni it can sometimes lose its magic; since you’ve spent so much time deconstructing something you aspire to create, some of the mysterious alchemy is laid bare. However, for me this sort of thing only rears its head when I’m sat in front of a bad film (I did a film degree) or a pants game – except deconstructing something that’s a bit ropey becomes an enjoyable experience in itself. ^_^ (Which kind of explains my strange obsession with videogame-to-film adaptations!)

    But when I go to see a film or play a game, if it really captures my imagination I become completely absorbed and any professionalism or deconstruction goes right out of the window. It’s just that it’s been a while that a game has really had such an effect on me. Having said that, exploring in Fallout 3, mastering the combat in Arkham Asylum and beating Splosion Man on Hardcore Mode all managed to really hook me in.

    (And ‘Gilo of Persia’ has a nice ring to it…odd though it is. Glad you liked the pic!) ^_^

    Ninja: I think immersion-breakers are a key thing to identify and try to overcome. Who knows – maybe decent motion control may be the answer? Achievements and Trophies are a massive part of the gaming landscape now, and as much as I love them I’m inclined to agree with Chris Hecker and Jesse Schell who gave fairly recent talks at GDC 10 and DICE 2010 respectively about the potentially harmful effects those little *per-plink*s are having on our hobby. Look them up, see what you think.

    As for returning to games for points…well…you’re not alone good sir! ^_^

    Mark: Coming from your good self, I’ll take your recommendation as very high praise indeed!

    Dean: I hear what you’re saying, I think we’re all guilty of nostalgia trying to put those rose-tinted glasses on us! The thing with nostalgia is that going back to old games is almost always going to be a disappointment – at the time they were state of the art, but only a few years later the gaming landscape has moved on. Likewise, games you play as you’re growing up will always have a special place in your heart since the narrative themes and gameplay mechanics resonated with you in a way that may not ring as true a few years later.

    But my issue isn’t ‘they don’t make ‘em like they used to’ (there’s good reason for that!), just that lately, for one reason or another, I’m finding it harder to really connect with games in the way I used to.

    Rook: I do like cheevos that make you go out of your way to try something you may not have otherwise, but only if they encourage you to pick up in-game skills or knowledge that enhance your overall experience. The thing I find is that by keeping an eye on a list that says ‘Go do this’ while playing a game for the first time, you’re very aware of something that is specifically outside of the game, creating distance between you and the game…removing the blinkers I guess.

  11. Simon avatar
    Simon

    Gilo – I get the same damn thing. When I was a nipper I knew every pixel of the Marion games and Bubble Bobble, but now I rush through games with my head down.

  12. Ninja avatar
    Ninja

    Thanks for the talk suggestions, I will definitely check them out; it’s always nice to catch a new perspective on things 🙂

  13. Jake avatar

    Tenchu 2: Birth of the Stealth Assassins; Prince of Persia Sands of Time and Resident Evil 2 🙂

  14. Blindmonkey avatar
    Blindmonkey

    I sympathize entirely with this. The worst thing is when you realize that you have a pile of games spanning several generations that you never got round to playing. As the stack of current generation games builds up you can’t help but wonder “will I ever actually get round to playing Super Mario RPG or Shinning Force 2 now?” And that makes me sad, as I’m sure I’m missing, or have missed out on, some great experiences. I put this question to a friend of mine who is takes game hoarding to ridiculous levels; and he replied quite matter of factly that he was storing them all up to play when he was retired. Video game pension plans anyone? I certainly feel like I play things these days just so that I can get it out the way and move onto the next, and because of that I hardly connect, let alone feel ‘at one’ as you put it, with anything. Now you’ve gone and made me all depressed.

  15. Giles avatar

    Jake – in the immortal words of Roy Walker, “It’s good, but it’s not right”. The Gilo No-Prize is still up for grabs people! Name all three games in the second image with the correct sub-titles (has to be word perfect) to win a wonderful, one of a kind Gilo No-Prize. ^_^

  16. Ninja avatar
    Ninja

    Hmm… Tenchu 2: Birth of the Stealth Assassins, Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time and Resident Evil 3: Nemesis?

    Props on the Stan Lee riff 😉

  17. Giles avatar

    Hehe! Always good to be among some true believers. ^_^

    Right…best have some feedback for the puzzle.

    Jake: You got one out of three (it would have been two out of three, but I am being an utter pedant here).

    Ninja: You got one out of three, though your pedantry (and Stan Lee reference-spotting) is to be commended.

    The No-Prize may be upgraded to include a bevvy at the soonest Ready Up meet… ^_^

  18. Ninja avatar
    Ninja

    Wait, there’s drinks at stake now?! Aw man… the soonest I’m hitting the mainland is the end of next month! *sad face* I’d try harder otherwise 😉

    At least we got one of them eliminated from sheer wrongness!

  19. Jamie Bishop avatar
    Jamie Bishop

    Giles, I too have an annoying ‘pile’ (childish giggle) that I’m currently trying to sift through and so can understand your plight! For better or worse (I haven’t decided yet) I have recently decided to fully complete each game before I allow myself to start a new one – meaning as many trophies/achievements as my gaming ability (and sanity) can manage. Its also the reason FFXIII is still eating up my time for those last two trophies while Demons Souls sits eagerly waiting.

    I can fully concur with your blog – I remember how much I was enjoying Fallout 3 last year, feeling fully immersed in its world, until that fateful moment I made it my aim to platinum it… it just seemed to zap the joy out of the whole thing… Darn Nuka Cola bottles…. Grumble Grumble… Nice blog by the way… Oh, and I’ll pass on the no-prize this time…

  20. Morrellium avatar
    Morrellium

    Yo! Nice blog Giles, i know exactly what you mean and as mentioned before, I too now get the feeling that when I decide to platinum games they suddenly become a chore (Resi 5 I’m looking at you!).

    Another factor as to why the immersion may have disappeared is money. Now I’m older and getting my own income, when I see a cheap game or new game I can say “yeah I’ll get that” and stick it on the pile. Whereas when I was younger, I either had to save up for months or wait for birthday/christmas before I got a new title. So I had to pick carefully because I knew I wouldn’t be getting another for a while, whereas now I can buy any old thing! Until the bank comes after me.

Leave a Reply